Embodying Heaven: The Body in Blake’s Dante, by Silvia Riccardi

Images of Transfiguration: Trasumanar and Transformation in Paradise

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 11.46.40

Screen Shot 2021-05-10 at 10.39.26

Introduction: Inside Blake’s Body

Dante’s journey in the otherworld has introduced generations of readers to the consequences of the divine judgment, the architecture of sin and salvation, the moral condemnation of materialism, and the pilgrim’s encounter with God. God is the “somma luce” (“eternal beam”), which cannot be grasped by means of human understanding. The blinding light of redemption thus remains a mystery untold in the Commedia.

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 11.41.08

“the sixty-seven-year-old William Blake approached Dante’s incommunicable experience by revisiting his poetics of line versus colour”

Toward the end of his life, the sixty-seven-year-old William Blake approached Dante’s incommunicable experience by revisiting his poetics of line versus colour. For his illustrations to the poem, he worked back and forth on 102 designs, leaving them in various stages of development. From Inferno to Paradiso through Purgatorio, Blake captured the condition of the fallen against the purity of the redeemed. Though the two are treated with the same medium, there is ambiguity in the conception of the human frame. Are the density and articulation of colours and contours in the Dante designs accidental modifications of form, or do they spell out the artist’s own judgment upon the souls?

The unfinished nature of the designs and the “breathtaking freedom of pencil work” (Bindman, William Blake, La Divina Commedia) are especially relevant in assessing the artist’s own response to the Commedia. Blake’s artistic maturity permeates his lines, which gain semantic relevance in his graphic translation of the poem. Examining the artisanal aspects of representing the human form in its fallen and saved conditions may shed light on the way that the artist projected abstract meaning into line and colour.

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 11.57.24

The Body is central to Blake’s Dante, as this image suggests, and indeed that is where the journey occurs.

Central to both Dante’s and Blake’s work is the treatment of the human body, which in relation to the illustrations to Purgatorio and Paradiso remains mostly under-explored. Tristanne Connolly notes that in Blake we can see “the human body exceed its present capabilities in two opposite directions, toward the hell of pain and contortion, and the heavenly beauty of flexible grace”. While Connolly refers to the illuminated books, her claim is also significant for the Dante illustrations.

A study of Blake’s theory against his practice may define the unutterable phenomenon of “Trasumanar,” the act of overcoming the mortal form of the body, in his pictorial lexicon. Claiming that his ascent from the Terrestrial Paradise to the celestial realm of the blessed cannot be expressed adequately in words, Dante invents the word trasumanar (“to transhumanize, to pass beyond the human”), the first of many neologisms in the Paradiso.

In Paradiso Dante coins this term, interpretable as going beyond the humus (earth) and the homo (corporeality). The word appears only once in the entire poem, when the poet explains that such an experience is inexpressible through the medium of language: “Trasumanar significar per verba / non si poria” (“Words may not tell of that transhuman change”). What follows will examine the way that Blake’s line and colour evoke “Trasumanar”—what Dante’s language fails to convey—in the sense of a divine, beatific experience and discuss how Blake’s artisanal aesthetics of the body enables such a phenomenon, in the Commedia possible only in Paradiso, to occur across the three cantiche.

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 12.07.51

Illustrating trasumanar: ‘The Ascension’ by Blake (c.1805-6 ). Not so much leaving the Body, as finally Entering it. It is to do with the nature of light, as Blake’s colours here suggest.

Screen Shot 2021-05-10 at 10.39.26

Section One: The poetics of line versus colour

Graphic lines are the most basic form through which Blake’s own ideas are embodied in his style. In A Descriptive Catalogue, the artist articulates his thoughts on artistic practice:

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 12.15.35

The Bounding Line: Blake’s own striking monogram

How do we distinguish one face or countenance from another, but by the bounding line and its infinite inflexions and movements? … Leave out this l[i]ne and you leave out life itself; all is chaos again, and the line of the almighty must be drawn out upon it before man or beast can exist.

Through this analogy, Blake urges us to focus on the very marks and lines that shape form and content out of the initial chaos of blurs of material execution.

Accordingly, in the watercolour series, the human body is distinguishable in both its fallen and transcended conditions. The graphic difference between the two states can be observed by comparing the outlining in The Stygian Lake, with the Ireful Sinners Fighting against Dante at the Moment of Entering the Fire.

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 12.18.36

“Comparing the outlining in The Stygian Lake, with the Ireful Sinners Fighting (above, left) against Dante at the Moment of Entering the Fire (above, right)”

In the first design, the sheer nudity of the sinners dominates the composition. Limbs, feet, and hands are exposed in great detail and dramatically marked by thick and solid strokes. The expressions of anger and lineaments of the face substantiate what Johann Caspar Lavater defines as “the relation between the exterior and the interior—between the visible surface and the invisible spirit which it covers—between the animated, perceptible matter, and the imperceptible principle which impresses this character of life upon it—between the apparent effect, and the concealed cause which produces it”. According to the Swiss theologian and physiognomist, a person’s face could mirror the soul’s virtue and vice, a sentiment that is echoed by Blake in “A Vision of the Last Judgment”:

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 12.23.05

“the relation between the exterior and the interior”: ‘Imagination of A man who Mr Blake has received instruction in Painting &c from’, sometimes also known as ‘The Visionary Self-portrait of William Blake’

Every Man has Eyes Nose & Mouth this Every Idiot knows but he who enters into & discriminates most minutely the Manners & Intentions the [Expression] Characters in all their branches is the alone Wise or Sensible Man & on this discrimination All Art is founded. I intreat then that the Spectator will attend to the Hands & Feet to the Lineaments of the Countenances they are all descriptive of Character & not a line is drawn without intention & that most discriminate & particular <as Poetry admits not a Letter that is Insignificant so Painting admits not a Grain of Sand or a Blade of Grass <Insignificant> much less an Insignificant Blur or Mark.

Blake shows a particular affinity with the physiognomic tradition in his poetics of the bounding line, whose execution in the Dante series achieves a clear distinction between the bodies of the damned and those of the saved.

His use of watercolour further characterizes the condition of the souls through their bodily mass. The sinners in the Stygian lake are densely coloured and contrasted. In the second design, the same combination of media results in a different effect. As opposed to contortion and opaqueness, the continuity of thin lines merging the elongated bodies with veils and flames, combined with the mild blue and magenta tones, suggests an ethereal sense of translucency. The purity of the souls is directly proportionate to the transparency of their corporeal density and the gradual thinning of the body line. The female spirits free themselves from the bonds of sin and gravity in their ascent along the wall of purgatorial fire, performing their ritual of purification. The angrily contorted sinners, on the other hand, are immersed in marshy waters.

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 12.26.01Christopher Heppner notes that “Blake, in inventing figures who explore and create a world of torment, drew support from Michelangelo’s portrayal of contorted and weightless figures”. The bodies of the wrathful resemble one of those cases where “the schema of a floating torso and legs” was borrowed from the Italian master. Though presented in “an aerial rather than terrestrial condition”, they are bound to their stagnant self-division at the bottom of the lake.

Screen Shot 2021-05-10 at 10.39.26

Section 2: The Opacity of the Ego

The graphic appearance of the bodies in Inferno seems to strengthen Eric Pyle’s claim that “the people in all the states of Hell have lost their ability to see infinity of which they are a part, and they believe that the boundary of themselves stops at what they call the body”.

Screen Shot 2021-11-01 at 19.00.58

The poet casting off the filthy rags of ego and materialism in Milton, in order to be able to see – and enter into – Reality.

Blake refers to this condition as Selfhood. Selfhood is a question of perception rather than of morality. Milton calls it both “a false Body: an Incrustation over my Immortal / Spirit” and “Satan”—“I in my Selfhood am that Satan: I am that Evil One! / He is my Spectre!” (Milton). Selfhood prevents humans from seeing beyond material surfaces to the Eternal World within.

The bodies of the ones confined in their fallen condition appear thus enclosed in themselves by means of the soul, which is “the source for its own constriction and obstruction” (Quinney). The closure of their senses is graphically reflected in their bodily outlines, dense materiality, and contracted postures, to the extent that it is difficult to discern human bodies from clusters of nonhuman matter.

The body line resembles rock formations, as, for instance, in the stony bridge made of giant human fragments in The Devils under the Bridge and the body-compound column to the left side of The Pit of Disease: The Falsifiers. In Dante, both bridges originate from a natural substance:

There is a place within the depths of hell

Call’d Malebolge, all of rock dark-stain’d

With hue ferruginous, e’en as the steep

That round it circling winds.

Screen Shot 2021-11-05 at 19.15.06

The Devils under the Bridge

………………………………………………

and as like fortresses,

E’en from their threshold to the brink without,

Are flank’d with bridges; from the rock’s low base

Thus flinty paths advanc’d, that ’cross the moles

And dikes struck onward far as to the gulf,

That in one bound collected cuts them off.

(Cary 1: 152-53; my emphasis)

Screen Shot 2021-11-05 at 19.15.13

The Pit of Disease: The Falsifiers

………………………………………………

We on the utmost shore of the long rock

Descended still to leftward. Then my sight

Was livelier to explore the depth, wherein

The minister of the most mighty Lord,

All-searching Justice, dooms to punishment

The forgers noted on her dread record.

(Cary 1: 254; my emphasis)

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 12.39.47

The materialists become like that which they behold

The opacity of the stones obstructs Satan’s sight of the divine the way colour density characterizes the condition of the fallen and the rocky architecture in the illustrations to Inferno.

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 12.40.34

The true face of materialism: like the Stones worshipped and revered by Urizen, imaginative vision eventually becomes petrified and inert.

While Dante describes the underworldly topography with peculiar realism, Blake conceptualizes the geology of the first cantica around the human body. Connolly comes to a similar conclusion when comparing the Gothic door in the frontispiece of Jerusalem with the infernal gate: “Like Dante’s, this is an entry into the world of the dead. While Dante’s inferno is a terrain which culminates in the body of the devil as a place to be tortured, for Blake the body plays a greater role in shaping the geography of hell”.

The occurrence of anatomical parts amalgamated with rock formations is distinctive to Blake’s imagery. The artist incorporates stone and flesh also in The Primaeval Giants Sunk in the Soil, where the five figures possibly stand for the five senses, “the chief inlets of Soul” (The Marriage of Heaven and Hell plate 4). For Blake, the senses are “windows, inlets, doors, gates, portals, or chinks in a body which is a wall, cave, shell, or building” (Mitchell). They may be “cleansed, enlarged, opened, multiplied, decorated, even passed through” and become “avenues of vision” revealing “portions of the eternal world” (Europe). They may also be “locked and barred, bricked up, narrowed, or dirtied”, as in the encapsulation of the giants in the shape of a rock. The senses are “fluxile” (Europe) and may be contracted or expanded:

every Word & Every Character

Was Human according to the Expansion or Contraction, the Translucence or

Opakeness of Nervous fibres such was the variation of Time & Space

Which vary according as the Organs of Perception vary

(Jerusalem)

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 11.43.37

The Primaeval Giants Sunk in the Soil. How the five senses work under the dominion of Urizen.

Blake shows the potential of the senses across the cantiche. On the one hand, the “Contraction” and “Opakeness of Nervous fibres” regulate contracted perception, or the limited condition of the material body, constrained within the laws of time and space. On the other hand, the “Expansion” and “Translucence” of “Nervous fibres” control expanded perception. Such a difference is rendered through the earthy and opaque matter of stone against air and fire, the elements that Blake combines instead with the cleansed souls. It also results in the predominance of bare and distorted frames in Inferno as opposed to the veiled figures in Purgatorio and Paradiso, which evoke the medieval aesthetics of an ethereal body.

Figures merging with their thin garments mirror Blake’s claim that “the Drapery is formed alone by the Shape of the Naked [next word cut away in binding]” body (Annotations to Reynolds’s Discourses). “Eloquence and significance in drapery cannot exist except in relation to a body,” Northrop Frye observes. “This is why all the human figures in Blake’s paintings are either naked or clad in the filmiest of nightdresses”. Instead of a realistic rendering of a clothed human figure, where one can discern the lines of the body and those of the clothes, the overall impression is that of an “aesthetic whole” (Lundeen). The line of the veiled body is especially pervasive in the illustrations to the second and third cantiche and acquires a semantic relevance in light of the entire poem. As opposed to confinement, it signifies transcendence of material form.

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 11.44.00

The Angel in the Boat Departing after Wafting Over the Souls for Purgation

This graphic phenomenon is noticeable even in sketchy drawings such as The Angel in the Boat Departing after Wafting Over the Souls for Purgation, where “figures are now graceful rather than contorted” (Bindman et al.). From these barely penciled lines, we can infer the vertical development of veiled and elongated shapes, as we do in The Terrace of Envious Souls.

The somatic difference between the fallen and the saved seems to be embedded in Blake’s line from the early conception of his pieces. Neither obscure nor unartistic, bodies that may appear puzzling are visual statements about his view of the condition of the soul. As Eaves points out, “Blake’s idea of the line in art is that it is the ultimate artistic act, an act with overtones of seeking the truth and making final judgments”. It is precisely through the bodily contours that Blake grants Dante and his guide, Virgil, the faculty of transcending their material forms prior to Paradiso.

Screen Shot 2021-11-05 at 19.16.01

The Inscription over the Gate. In a sense they are entering not ‘Hell’ but a degraded state of the body itself. A body that is seen in terms of judgement, and quantity, and solidity – the objectifying fictions of the Urizenic mode.

The presence of the veiled line can accordingly be traced in Inferno, where the two figures exhibit different strokes compared to the bulky mass of the sinners. In The Inscription over the Gate, the lower part of their vestures becomes one with their legs and feet. The fading red and blue tints enhance a sense of translucence. Dante and Virgil appear as two light, elongated entities who are almost levitating as they approach the infernal gate. This quasi-ethereal effect signals a fundamental difference between the ways in which Dante and Blake envisioned the bodies of the two poets in Inferno. While in the Commedia “Dante-personaggio possesses a body that is heavy and opaque (it cannot be penetrated by rays of sunlight) and whose members allow him to breathe and move objects” (Gilson), in the watercolour series he appears to lose his material form even in some early designs.

Dante at the Moment of Entering the Fire offers an example of this phenomenon from Purgatorio. Dante is urged by Virgil and the angel above to enter the flames animated by female spirits. The sense of incorporeality is conveyed by graphic lines thinning gradually and merging with other forms, as if the figures were translucent. Clothes, bodies, and flames flow harmoniously upward, evoking the sense of “Trasumanar” introduced by Dante in Paradiso.

In this canto, Dante draws an analogy between the Ovidian metamorphosis of Glaucus and his own experience of elevation toward God: “tu ’l sai, che col tuo lume mi levasti” (“Thou know’st, who by thy light didst bear me up,” Cary 3: 8). The poet is unable to tell whether he is in or out of his body; the boundaries between the physical and the non-physical space are blurred. While for Dante this phenomenon occurs only in Paradiso and is incommunicable to the reader except through the mythical esemplo of Glaucus (“l’essemplo basti / a cui esperïenza grazia serba” [“Let the example serve, though weak, / For those whom grace hath better proof in store,” Cary 3: 8]), Blake envisions a transcendence of the material condition regardless of the place in the otherworld—whether Inferno, Purgatorio, or Paradiso—and makes this phenomenon graphically visible. For Blake, “Hell is a state and not a place” (Pyle), and his line embodies this view fully.

Screen Shot 2021-05-10 at 10.39.26

Section 3: The Deep Truth is Imageless

Dante’s belief in the absolute transcendence of God is the inherent reason for his poetic limitations. He cannot describe his vision experienced in the highest Paradiso as, for him, it is beyond expression. For Blake, vision is instead the active process of creation. In a passage referring to his painting of the Last Judgment, the artist invites us to immerse ourselves in the images rendered in this work to gain access to the divine vision of God:

Screen Shot 2021-05-28 at 16.11.44

“On the Fiery Chariot of his Contemplative Thought”. This is an image both of the Chariot, and the Chariot itself seeing the image (‘Beatrice Addressing Dante from the Car’)

If the Spectator could Enter into these Images in his Imagination approaching them on the Fiery Chariot of his Contemplative Thought if he could Enter into Noahs Rainbow or into his bosom or could make a Friend & Companion of one of these Images of wonder which always intreats him to leave mortal things as he must know then would he arise from his Grave then would he meet the Lord in the Air & then he would be happy. 

This passage is crucial to understanding Blake’s view of the great potential of his art and his belief that God is accessible via imagination. How, then, does his fundamental disagreement with Dante on the absolute immanence of God take the form of a visual statement in the watercolour series? A comparative analysis of the two poets’ beliefs may help to define this line of inquiry.

Until Dante’s entrance in Paradiso, his experience in the afterlife is regulated by his senses. He is “the only living character in the Commedia and the only one to possess a human body, a fleshy exterior that is liable to change and corruption” (Gilson). Dante undergoes a journey through his material body and forms an understanding of his encounters on the basis of his sensory inputs, growing in awareness and learning to recognize his limits. His conception of physical responses is consistent with the medieval Aristotelian view that all human knowledge originates in sense perception. Sense perception is then developed in images through imagination, memory, and “possible intellect.” These images are turned into abstractions in order to be processed by the “active intellect”.

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 18.21.06

How the fallen body experiences reality. Perhaps a good way to understand this is by the metaphor not of opacity and solidity, or contraction, but of being ‘frozen’. It is a cold, reptilian state, which sees everything upside down and inside out: it thinks that ‘reality’, for example, exists ‘outside’. It alters the fluid, ever-changing River of life, and sees it merely as a collection of ‘things’ – a dreadful fallen phase state, separate from itself. Blake calls this state, following Dante, ‘Lucifer’.

According to Dante, it is the combination of perception, imagination, and memory regulated by intellect that originates poetic ingegno (virtue), of which he avails himself in order to produce poetry. Nevertheless, and closer to a Neoplatonic view, poetic ingegno is regulated by the stars of Gemini in Paradiso 22.112-23, where he seeks their support to write about the “passo forte” (“hard emprize,” Cary 3: 203). Notably, Dante also finds dreams (Purgatorio 27) and supernatural inspiration (Paradiso 33) to be sources of knowledge. Eventually, he realizes that the body should be inhabited as a place of relationship and transition. It is under this condition that Dante can witness various corporeal forms.

The sinners he encounters in Inferno appear to him as material bodies. The materiality of the souls relates to the notion of evil as immersion in matter in line with the Neoplatonic tradition. According to this view, the human being is the result of the union between the body and the divine soul and represents a fall into materiality. The bodies of the sinners are described as injured, deformed, and mutilated. In Purgatorio, the reconciled, airy figures of the souls are described in their meekness and rediscovered communion, as Statius explains in Purgatorio. In Paradiso, the human outlines of the blessed, except for Beatrice, initially recede from Dante’s sight behind the spiritual light of their eternal joy. It is only in Paradiso 33 that Dante experiences the divine vision, after Bernard asks the Virgin Mary to allow Dante’s sight to see the divine light. Note that the Virgin Mary intercedes through sight and not through actions. Dante is able to gaze into the light but is unable to recount his experience, as words as well as memory are not sufficient to describe it:

Thenceforward, what I saw,

Was not for words to speak, nor memory’s self

To stand against such outrage on her skill.

(Cary 3: 293)

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 11.44.25

The Souls of Those Who Only Repented at the Point of Death. The judgmental mind thinks that Hell is a result or state of Judgement. It is not: it is merely the objective correlative of an inner ‘hell’. Materiality is not to do with the body or form, which is Divine, but is rather a psychological way of seeing or understanding that Body. We “fall” into this way of seeing the body – the world – when we make the Emissary (Urizen, Lucifer) the Master. As McGilchrist notes, materialism is an under-valuation, not an over-valuation, of the body: “Materialists, as I suggested earlier, are not people who overvalue, but who undervalue, matter. They see it only under Scheler’s lowest realm of value: that of utility and sensation” (The Master and his Emissary).

Blake was skeptical of Dante’s mimetic approach to poetry and the assumptions of his poetic ingegno. Imagination was not, as Dante believed after Aquinas, “like a treasure house of images received by the senses” (“est enim phantasia sive imaginatio quasi thesaurus quidam formarum per sensum acceptarum”). According to Blake, mere reflections of nature are devoid of creative effort. Imagination is the artist’s tool in overcoming such pitfalls of creation, as he “could visualize things not actually before his eyes” (Damon) and his “artistic line is the expression of personal identity … the direct expression of imagination” (Eaves).

Blake’s task as an artist is therefore

To open the Eternal Worlds, to open the immortal Eyes

Of Man inwards into the Worlds of Thought: into Eternity

Ever expanding in the Bosom of God. the Human Imagination

(Jerusalem 5.18-20, E 147)

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 12.00.49

“to open the immortal Eyes/ Of Man inwards into the Worlds of Thought: into Eternity/ Ever expanding in the Bosom of God. the Human Imagination”. Image: Gustave Doré. Beatrice leads Dante into the Empyrean, or highest level of Heaven, where he beholds the angels and souls of the blessed forming a snow white rose in attendance upon the Deity (Paradiso: XXXI, 1-3).

He makes this process visible by rendering the phenomenon of expanded perception through bodily outlines that extend themselves out of the human frame and merge with other forms, such as veils and flames in Dante at the Moment of Entering the Fire and veils in The Souls of Those Who Only Repented at the Point of Death. This unfinished piece shows the souls of the late repentant as if they were clothed in their expanded aura of perception. The graphic treatment of the body creates material ambiguity, which results in a non-objective space. The third soul from the bottom left exhibits folds of tissue or fabric developing from the lower part of the body to the feet. The left hand is graphically connected to that of the next soul through thin lines. The visual continuity between the two figures is reinforced by the negative space created by the absence of blue wash. Colour highlights the perceptual aura of the soul on the bottom left, where we distinguish yellow threads of luminescence interlacing the anatomical lines and diffusing into the air. The function of colour, “the language of the senses,” is here subordinate to the line, “the language of the intellect” (Eaves).

As observed in The Inscription over the Gate, traces of translucency may also be identified in the first cantica, Inferno being a state rather than a place. In The Circle of the Lustful, Blake likewise grants Paolo and Francesca the capacity to transcend their material forms. Unlike the other transgressors, the two souls are locked together. The lines of the lovers define two veiled figures blending together as they flutter in the air. Their aura of expanded perception is suggested by wavy patterns developing from and into their limbs, torsos, and hair. A projection of the embracing couple is also represented in the shining sun above the two poets. This piece shows that Blake was following the text closely—a senseless Dante on the ground, the gentle couple detached from the sinful crowd, the strong wind blowing across the circle of the lustful—yet challenging it. The episode of Paolo and Francesca, along with that of Ugolino, was well known in Romantic England. In Dante we read of his encounter with the noble couple in the second circle of Inferno, where the sinners are incessantly tossed around in a whirlwind. In the celebrated passage, Francesca recounts the moment of falling in love in stilnovistic terms:

Love, that in gentle heart is quickly learnt,

Entangled him by that fair form, from me

Ta’en in such cruel sort, as grieves me still:

Love, that denial takes from none belov’d,

Caught me with pleasing him so passing well,

That, as thou see’st, he yet deserts me not.

Love brought us to one death: Caina waits

The soul, who split our life.

(Cary 1: 45-46)

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 11.42.34

The Circle of the Lustful. “Blake likewise grants Paolo and Francesca the capacity to transcend their material forms”. Lust, like pornography, is again an under-valuation, not an over-valuation, of the body. It is a body reduced to a thing, psychologically encountered merely in terms of ‘use’ and ‘sensation’.

Paolo’s “gentle” heart was enraptured by Francesca, whose living character was deprived of her noble heart when she could not deny love—the same love leads Paolo and Francesca to death and eternal suffering. Even though Dante faints, overwhelmed by compassion—“come corpo morto cade” (Inf. 5.142) (“like a corse fell to the ground,” Cary 1: 48)—he sees no hope for the couple to be redeemed in accordance with the sentiment set by the inscription before the infernal gate: “Lasciate ogne speranza, voi ch’intrate” (Inf. 3.9) (“All hope abandon, ye who enter here,” Cary 1: 21).

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 18.56.07

Blake’s manifesto of liberation: How to get from hell to heaven: enter the Body. “This will come to pass by an improvement of sensual enjoyment. But first the notion that man has a body distinct from his soul is to be expunged.”

Regardless of the infernal dictum, Blake allows Paolo and Francesca to leave their mortal bodies, since he sees the pleasures of the flesh as a means to overcome the fall of humankind and to make the world “appear infinite. and holy whereas it now appears finite & corrupt. This will come to pass by an improvement of sensual enjoyment” (Marriage plate 14). Blake disagreed with the system of punishments in Inferno, as it did not reflect the doctrine of forgiveness preached by Jesus, but rather an alignment with tyrannical attitudes. Although he called Dante “an Emperors <a Caesars> Man,” he nevertheless appreciated the Italian poet among the “Men of Genius” and remarked to Henry Crabb Robinson that “Dante (tho’ now with God) lived & died an Atheist—He was the slave of the world & time—But Dante & Wordsw: in spight of their Atheism were inspired by the Holy Ghost” (Bentley, Records). As Paley comments, The Circle of the Lustful “reminds us that some of Blake’s greatest achievements are as a straightforward illustrator, but one who interprets the text imaginatively and uses his own pictorial vocabulary” (Traveller 128-29). The expanded perception rendered through graphic lines in the bodies of Paolo and Francesca pertains to his lexicon.

Screen Shot 2021-05-10 at 10.39.26

Conclusion: The Transfiguration of Form: Expanding into God

Perceptual contraction and expansion may thus occur at various stages in the watercolour series, as “Trasumanar” is not locked within one dimension only. If we avail ourselves of our “infinite senses” by “expanding” our perception, “we behold as one” (Jerusalem). We see one being or process in a multitude, we interconnect instead of disconnecting. In Blake’s words:

My Eyes more & more

Like a Sea without shore

Continue Expanding

The Heavens commanding

Till the Jewels of Light

Heavenly Men beaming bright

Appeard as One Man

(E 713)

Brightness and light characterize the “Heavens,” where “Men” appear “as One Man.” The union between God and humans embodies Blake’s idea of subjectivity, according to which the condition of the self is not individual in essence but rather a fluid state of being, or a version of what Tim Ingold terms “in-betweenness.” In-betweenness is “a movement of generation and dissolution in a world of becoming where things are not yet given … but on the way to being given. … Where between is liminal, in-between is arterial; where between is intermediate, in-between is midstream. And the in-between is the realm of the life of lines” (italics in the original).

By expanding the boundaries among living beings and making this process visible, Blake seeks unity between “Men” and God. For him, unlike for Dante, God is thus immanent in all of us: “All Things are comprehended in their Eternal Forms in the Divine body of the Saviour the True Vine of Eternity The Human Imagination”. The fundamental difference between Blake’s and Dante’s approaches to “Trasumanar” therefore lies in the two poets’ underlying assumptions and means of representation. While Dante does not regard imagination as a divine power, Blake believes that

The Eternal Body of Man is The Imagination. that is God himself

The Divine Body Jesus we are his Members

Dante identifies the divine intervention necessary for “Trasumanar” in God himself, whereas Blake sees it in the divine power of imagination—that is God. As a result, in Dante’s allegory such an experience is only possible in Paradiso, the realm where God dwells, and incommunicable outside of this place. In Blake’s view, Paradiso is a state rather than a place. Via imagination, we may find God within us at any stage of our journey.

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 19.12.48

The Resurrection into the Body: Trasumanar.

Blake’s pictorial “Trasumanar” culminates in the highly evocative piece of Dante Adoring Christ. The fine work of line-making unifies the bodies of Dante and Christ with their veiled garments and dynamic auras. Bindman accurately observes that the “‘glitterance of Christ’ is wonderfully suggested by Blake’s use of watercolour”. The artist skillfully combines pencil and watercolour to achieve a sense of immateriality, which stands in stark contrast to the corporeality of Vanni Fucci “Making Figs” against God. The outlines of the muscular physiques of Vanni Fucci and Christ are strikingly different. With regard to engraving, Connolly specifies that “if Blake wished to make his representations of muscles more subtle, he could have done so, avoiding the hardness of printed lines by drawing or painting in musculature at a later stage”. Blake’s practice of designing the musculature within the copperplate could not occur in the watercolour designs. Nevertheless, the artist exposes his subjects by over-marking the internal muscles with pencil and watercolour, yet distinguishing bold contours for the damned versus light and flexible lineaments for the blessed. While the anatomy of Christ becomes one with the veils developing from his torso in thin pencil strokes and touches of colour, the body of the thief is heavily contrasted, rendering the effect of what Blake refers to as “temptations and perturbations, labouring to destroy Imaginative power, by means of that infernal machine, called Chiaro Oscuro, in the hands of Venetian and Flemish Demons”.

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 19.28.43

An unhappy soul, still persecuted by his own Superego (Vanni Fucci “Making Figs” against God, left), and a happy soul (Dante Adoring Christ, right), having realised the way out – through the transcendent form of forgiveness, mutual interdependence, and imaginative creation (the ‘Body’, the True Vine of the universe).

The use of colour also matters in the respective backgrounds of the designs. Inferno is rocky and clouded by clusters of dense, opaque matter exhibiting a dramatic juxtaposition of red and yellow, as opposed to the the airy, light-toned aura enveloping the body of Christ in Paradiso. Both Vanni Fucci and Christ are similarly depicted, in a standing position with outstretched arms. Janet Warner identifies in this posture and its variations an ambiguous archetype, which can be interpreted as a demonic impulse or its regenerative counterpart. Vanni Fucci and Christ seem to substantiate this ambiguity—while the former delivers a blasphemous gesture to the sky, the latter evokes the iconographic tradition of self-sacrifice and invites us to “enter Blake’s Paradiso with the worship of the Human Form Divine” (Paley, Traveller 165). The two illustrations exhibit a noticeable difference in the use of the same medium. The opacity of Vanni Fucci’s body resembles the effect of those watercolour pieces described by Anthony Blunt as “almost as if he [Blake] was painting in tempera”. Christ’s translucency is, instead, about minimal touches of pigment. The artist seems to suggest a visual hierarchy among the inhabitants of Dante’s otherworld in accordance with his advocacy for line over colour.

In the three years before his death, Blake returned to his poetics of line versus colour and defined it as a point of access into the experience of the beyond in his Dante illustrations. He challenged the architecture of sin and salvation, “seeking to understand the poem by discovering his disagreements with it” (Pite). The mystery of God, untold in the Commedia, thus finds its graphic manifestation in the watercolour series. The artist achieved the ineffability of mystical experiences via his eidetic images, as “when the influence of the imagination is at its maximum, they [optical perceptual (or eidetic) images] are ideas that, like afterimages, are projected outward and literally seen” (Jaensch; italics in the original). In Blake’s words, “He who does not imagine in stronger and better lineaments, and in stronger and better light than his perishing and mortal eye can see does not imagine at all”. He gave lineaments and form to Dante’s linguistic impossibilities through a skillful articulation of the medium across the three cantiche.

While high colour density and solid contours may signify the condition of the fallen and the opacity of “a false Body: an Incrustation over my Immortal / Spirit; a Selfhood” (Milton), the veiled line and subtle strokes of colour bring us closer to what Dante’s “words may not tell”—“Trasumanar significar per verba / non si poria” (Par. 1.70-71). The incorporated manifestations of the body in the line allow us to conceptualize the range of meanings generated by Blake’s practice in light of his aesthetic theory. By acknowledging the semantic value of contours and colour density, we move beyond anatomical discrepancies on a merely representational level and access the artist’s use of line and colour as instruments for revealing the Eternal World within. The soul’s journey toward God, in the poem achieved in the third cantica exclusively, becomes in Blake’s designs a journey within ourselves, for Inferno, Purgatorio, and Paradiso are not places but rather states where God, by means of imagination, is within us.

Screen Shot 2021-11-06 at 19.11.22

The Body, finally free from the persecutory and limiting rationalising Mind. Image: ‘The Christian Triumph’, from Blake’s Illustrations to Edward Young’s Night Thoughts (c. 1795-97), showing the release of the Body.

This is an edited version of The Body in the Line:’ Trasumanar’ in Blake’s Dante, by Silvia Riccardi. To read the full article, please click here.

Silvia Riccardi is a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Uppsala. She has written on the reception of Dante in England and is currently working on Blake’s graphic and textual forms of biomorphism as well as on a book project on the aesthetics of Dark Romanticism.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s